The Best Butt Plugs For Men

Whether you’re a newbie or a seasoned plugger, there’s something for everyone in this collection. Experts suggest looking for toys made from non-porous materials like silicone, glass, porcelain, and metal (porous ones hang onto butt bacteria).

And remember to always use lube during long-wear. That will help you avoid painful anal irritation and even small internal tears.

Fun Factory Bootie Butt Plug

A butt plug with a bit of a twist, the Bootie is a smooth toy that will please your anus while stimulating your clit. The flange (base) on this anal plug nestles intuitively between your cheeks, and the tulip tip grazes the prostate, arousing the sensitive area. It may look delicate, but this little beauty was made for powerful orgasms.

Fun Factory’s products are always super safe and designed with the body best butt plugs for men in mind. Their medical-grade, non-porous silicone is super soft and able to be sterilized with boiling water. Just add a little water-based lube and you’re ready to play.

This bestselling anal plug is the little black dress of butt toys, perfect for beginner anal play and an excellent addition to masturbation or partner sex for anyone of any experience level. During intercourse, Bootie Fem’s asymmetrical base with one shorter end won’t block the vaginal opening, and pressure from the tulip tip temporarily narrows the anal canal to guide your partner toward the G-spot for a thrilling squeeze.

After play, clean this fun anal plug with a squirt of your favorite sex toy cleaner or antibacterial toy cleanser and a little soap and water. Rinse it and let it dry completely before you put it away. Like all erotic toys, use it with caution and with a condom (if you want). Autostraddle runs on reader support. If you enjoy what we do, you can show your appreciation by becoming an AF+ Member.

Njoy Stainless Steel Butt Plug

One of the best butt plugs out there, the Njoy Pure is a sensual piece designed to up your anal stimulation game. Cast in 316 stainless steel, this smooth and shiny toy feels pure and safe in the hand, making it easy to manipulate for a range of sensations. It’s completely body-safe and non-porous, so it won’t rust or corrode over time, and you can heat it up in the microwave to make it extra hot for sensation play, or cool it down for a chilling experience.

The head is shaped for P-spot stimulation and has dips to enhance penetration, while the tapered base is slightly curved for comfort in the anal canal. Stainless steel is also heavy, giving the Pure a luxurious feel that makes it perfect for long-term use.

It’s recommended to use silicone or oil-based lubricant with this plug as the metal can be a bit dry, and you’ll want to keep it hydrated for the best results. Cleaning is pretty easy as well, simply wash your plug in warm water and a little Before and After foaming cleanser to keep it hygienic.

Tantus Perfect Plug Kit

If you’re looking to start anal exploration, or just need a plug that won’t cause you too much pain during insertion, the Tantus Perfect Plug Kit is the way to go. This kit comes with two different anal toys, both Curved Dual Ended Anal Plug made from body-safe silicone and featuring a smooth, body-conforming shape that’s designed to hit all the sweet spots and stay put.

The first toy in the kit is the slender Perfect Plug, which measures a maximum of 3.5 inches insertable and has a 0.75″ diameter at its widest point. The plug’s long, slender neck is tailored to be easily retainable while the anchor base tapers to fit flawlessly between the cheeks.

If the initial anal plug doesn’t provide enough fullness or p-spot stimulation for you, the larger Perfect Plug Plus is available as well. This plug is a little beefier than the original, measuring a max of 4 inches insertable and 1.2″ in diameter at its widest point. It also comes with a 3-speed removable bullet vibrator to up the intensity of your anal play.

Both plugs are made from the company’s own unique formula of 100% ultra premium silicone, which is easy to clean, eco-friendly, hypoallergenic, hygienic, boilable, bleachable and dishwasher safe. You can even use the plug with a water-based lubricant, which is recommended if you want to get the most out of this toy.

Lelo Hugo

The Lelo Hugo is an exceptional dual prostate stimulator with a unique remote control, impressive battery life and a variety of stimulating vibrations to explore. The toy has a longer arm that is primarily intended to fit snugly into the anal canal, while the smaller end rests against the perineum to deliver extra stimulation there.

This toy is made with body-safe silicone and has a beautiful matte finish that feels smooth and satisfying. The material also resists heat and stains, so you won’t have to worry about it retaining nasty smells or germs after prolonged use. It’s also easy to clean with warm water, making it a great choice for repeated use.

To use the Hugo, simply lube up and insert it into your anus. It’s a good idea to apply a liberal amount of lube, both to the toy and to the anal area, as this will make insertion comfortable and increase the pleasure during anal play.

The Lelo Hugo is an expensive butt plug, so it’s not for everyone. However, it offers an exceptional level of satisfaction for men who enjoy prostate massagers and can justify the price tag. It’s also a fantastic gift for an adventurous partner! This toy is also very discreet. It comes in a sleek black box that looks just like any other product, so you can use it without worrying about people figuring out you’re into prostate play.